Last week was dominated by an emerging Republican narrative about Democrats: Dems are socialists. They are an angry mob. They frighten ordinary people. The framing by Trump is that the mid-term election is âpatriots vs. socialistsâ.
And Trump said this on Friday night in Cincinnati:
A vote for a Republican is a vote to reject the Democratic politics of hatred, anger and division.
The Democratsâ closing argument for the mid-terms is considerably more nuanced, and it may not be heard clearly. They are against Trump, and all that he and his party stand for, but they talk about wanting a chance to provide a âcheck and balanceâ against Trumpâs (and the GOPâs) worst instincts.
Sure, some will vote for that, but will enough turn out to vote for it to take the House?
The Democrats havenât recovered from the publicâs disapproval of their demonstrations against Kavanaugh after his swearing in. A reasonable minority of Dems donât understand that most Americans are uncomfortable with demonstrations. Amy Chua has an astute observation in her book, âPolitical Tribesâ where she quotes a South Carolina student:
I think protesting is almost a status symbol for elites. Thatâs why they always post pictures on Facebook, so all their friends know theyâre protesting. When elites protest on behalf of us poor people, itâs not just that we see them as unhelpful; it seems that they are turning us…into the next âmemeâ. We donât like being used for someone elseâs self-validation.
On one side, we have the GOP, who can apparently say anything, offer insults and tell lies. On the other side, we have the Democrats who canât do much of that without the mainstream media taking umbrage. Dems allow the media and the Right to write their story. The GOP and the media have made the Democrats the party of identity politics, the PC party, one that is so busy protecting the big tent that itâs unable to govern.
Trumpâs Traveling Nuremberg Rallies will continue until the mid-terms, and Dems must decide what messaging will be successful in 2018. Itâs going to be tough, because since the dawn of time, no one has truly figured out how to deal effectively (and conclusively) with authoritarian and anti-democratic ideas.
But, Dems have to do just that, or else remain a fringe party.
In American politics, it seems like itâs always 1968. Republicans are the law-and-order party. Democrats are the party affiliated with the demonstrators in the streets of Chicago, even though those demonstrators were radicals, not Democrats. The demonstrators were furious at the Vietnam War, which was led then by Democrats. And today, that viewpoint persists.
Both parties think the other is appalling, so you donât have to like your own party, you just have to hate the other one. And one thing the Kavanaugh mess has done, itâs made both sides feel the other is appalling.
How it all turns out 22 days from now is anyoneâs guess. Letâs hope the Democrats fight hard for the issues that really matter. On to cartoons.
Itâs football and election seasons, and itâs always tough to pick the winners:
Itâs laughable to think back to the days when the US sent observers to other countries to ensure fair elections:
Nikki Haley resigned. Kanye went to the White House. What to expect next:
Hurricanes have become like school shootings, so many of them, and all so devastating. We treat these events the same, with thought and prayers, but no plan to deal with the causes:
What Trump and Fox want the campaign trail to look like:
Trump sprang into action after Jamal Khashoggiâs disappearance. He said we shouldnât jeopardize our arms sales to Saudi Arabia:
I have heard Amy Chua’s observation. I have not read her work. Still, I don’t see elites as protesting more than anyone else. In fact, elites travel and sip wine in nice places etc. I think the small town folks don’t like what they view as city folks. It does not mean we are not tribal but they would hate elites if they drove large trucks down main street. They hate city folks period. Worse, small town folks listen in a bubble. So we can’t reach them. So they see far more of the protest (exaggerated by Fox) than we do. I work in NYC and the city was not awash with protest. Washington was. and the deplorables were not turned off by tea party protests a decade ago. So I just disagree with glib analysis
@ Terry: I take your point that some rural and small town people hate city slickers, even if they show up driving a truck with truck nuts on the back bumper. That shows there are palpable distinctions between groups, regardless if the differences are economic, educational, race, religion or geography. I am reading Chua’s book now, and am not ready to recommend it just yet.
I recommend: American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America by Colin Woodard. A different grouping of our tribes. My son recommended it to me. I give is 4 our of 5 stars.